Summary
Summary - Introduction to Forensic Psychology
- Course
- Institution
Summary of all course material in the course Introduction to Forensic Psychology in year 2022/23.
[Show more]
1 review
By: mtcodrington • 9 months ago
By: solutiont • 9 months ago
Hello, could you tell me what is not up to your standards? Last year we had a different lecturer, and the information might not be up to date, hence the year in the description.
Seller
Follow
solutiont
Reviews received
Content preview
Introduction to Forensic PsychologyLiterature lecture 1
Badness, madness and the brain – the late 19th-century controversy on immoral
persons and their malfunctioning brains
William Bigg – killer of animals, molester of girls, torturer of siblings – ‘moral insanity or
congenital defect of the moral sense’ – linking immorality and neurobiology – immoral due
to disordered brain
Bad brains, bad persons: Historical background
o Beginning of 19th century – the reconceptualization of mental disorders as
encompassing all aspects of the human mind and behavior
o Pinel – insanity as mental disease that affects emotions, moral insanity, homicidal
mania
o Medical model of vice as pathology
o 19th century onwards – neuro/biology played a significant role in explaining mental
disorders
o Hereditary dominated at that point – immoral people – offspring of immoral
ancestry
o Theory of degeneration – it was hereditary, but also progressively worse with each
generation
o Darwin – morality as a high and complex development of a species – immorality is
reverse
o Cerebral underpinnings – moral areas in the skull (Gall and Spurzheim) – Moritz
Benedikt – occipital lobes
o Mental disorders of morality – brain dysfunctions
o Brain mediated external causes
Exemplary cases
William Bigg
o Torturing animals, his siblings
o Dangerous, vicious, cunning, devious, infantile, humorless, naïve
o Moral insanity – unethical behavior
o Older and more barbaric lower functions were uncontrolled and elicited wicked
behavior
o Brain-based explanations of immorality pose a legal responsibility
Charles J. Guiteau
o Heredity as a connection between neurological and mental disease
, o Abnormal brain – if that was the case then the autopsy needs to show it
Jane Toppan
o Nurse who murdered employers
o Not guilty by reason of insanity, became delusional in the asylum
o Insanity via hereditary – corrupted family
Patient E.
o No hereditary burden – however withdrawn and uncommunicative but imaginative
o Devious, manipulative
o ‘’moral idiot’’
o Cortex function ‘defective’ however no proof
Christiana Edmunds
o Defective brain
o Chocolate cream poisoner
o Intellect immaculate, no remorse for the poisonings
o Brain-based explanations – moral life is not an option
Bad brains, bad persons: late 19th century
Brain-based explanations for immorality
o many biological explanations
o Heredity, degeneration, evolutionary reversion and brain-based models
o Difference in opinions – brain-based explanations were not convincing then
Evidence for immoral brains
o No technologies to actually study it
o Dead brain analysis – no actual evidence but still a potent explanation
Immorality as mental disorder
o Moral mania, moral imbecility, moral insanity, moral derangement
o Immorality as epiphenomenon or symptom
Immorality VS criminality
o Biomedical explanations for criminality
o Difficult to discriminate between immoral lunatics in mere criminals
Rethinking immoral persons in terms of bad brains
o Observation, evaluation and reprimand
o New domain of predisposing and eliciting conditions – added to personhood and
moral state
o Divesting immoral persons of responsibility
, o Brain is nature – cannot be held accountable, people cannot be liable
o Also ramifications for the penal system
A new controversy: a contemporary case
o Brian Dugan – hampered functioning of brain
o Difference in today’s cases – contexts differ, hereditary explanations are less salient,
and models of genetics are not similar
o Brain as a NETWORK, not a localized thing
Conclusion
o Brain-based views in the 19th century were contested
o Neurological bases diverse – alluded dysfunction, not demonstrated
o emphasis on an immoral person’s adverse neurobiological constituents
indicated changes in thinking about immoral persons at the end of the 19th-century
o unity of neurobiology, mental disorder and immorality
o brain is evoked differently now
Lecture 1
Clinical forensic psychology – deviant behavior, personality, cognitions, prevention,
intervention, diagnostics, the intersection of different psychology disciplines, law, and
psychiatry
Examples of clinical forensics and the judicial system – are police and temporary
incarceration, prisons, penitentiary psychiatric centers (PPCs), pro-Justitia reporting, mental
health institutions on several levels, TBS clinics
A criminal career starts at an early age, with downward spiral problems, persistent problems
Become an expert on mental health care of youth and adult offenders, scientist-practitioner
– critically thinking about clinical practice, tackling, and analyzing issues from practice
History of forensic psychology
o Hippocrates
o Middle Ages – the right of containment (lock-up), legal guardianship lies with the
family
o 15th-17th century – the enlightenment
15th century – Madhouses
Possessed by the devil – witch hunts (16th-17th century)
Johannes Wier
- A turning point – age of enlightenment
o 18th century – French Evolution
o 1810 – Code Penal (France) – very strict
o 1809 in NL – Criminal Code of Law, 1811 – Code Penal (NL)
, o 1886 – Introduction of Code of Law
o More attention to psychological disorders – scientific approach
o Great Britain – moral treatment
o Several laws for containing mentally disordered
19th century
- Pinel – manie sans delire – state of mind without delusions
o More cases in which offenders are not punished on account of mental
conditions
- 1841. First Krankzinnigenwet – more supervision and improvement
- Later: TBS – severe offenses, not fully responsible, high risk of reoffending
Four explanations of mental disorders and crime:
- Heredity – psychological traits inherited from ancestors, heredity of criminal
behavior, immoral behavior deduced from physical traits
- Degeneration
- Evolution
- Neurological explanations
Juvenile criminal law – 19th and 20th century
- Before – no distinction between children and adults
- During Code Penal – without distinguishing judgement
- 1905 introduction – Kinderwetten
- From punishment and avenging to betterment
- Shift to modern law streams – importance of the offender not the offense – aimed at
betterment, appropriate and milder punishment
20th century
- Van Hamel proposition:
o Mild offenses – regulations or conviction – the aim is DETERRENCE
o Serious offenses – LT treatment
o Very serious offenses – TBR, 10-year treatment followed by reevaluation
o 1928 -Psychopathenwetten – TBS and treatment included in Dutch Law
o Many new institutions – Stop-law in 1933
Development after WWII
- Commission after-war law – nuanced view
- Utrecht school: Baan, Pompe, and Kempe – internationally leading
- Better care for offenders and special care for offenders with a mental disorder
- ’60 – increase duration TBS regulations
- Ca. 1995 – introduction Longstay facilities
Punishment or treatment?
The benefits of buying summaries with Stuvia:
Guaranteed quality through customer reviews
Stuvia customers have reviewed more than 700,000 summaries. This how you know that you are buying the best documents.
Quick and easy check-out
You can quickly pay through credit card or Stuvia-credit for the summaries. There is no membership needed.
Focus on what matters
Your fellow students write the study notes themselves, which is why the documents are always reliable and up-to-date. This ensures you quickly get to the core!
Frequently asked questions
What do I get when I buy this document?
You get a PDF, available immediately after your purchase. The purchased document is accessible anytime, anywhere and indefinitely through your profile.
Satisfaction guarantee: how does it work?
Our satisfaction guarantee ensures that you always find a study document that suits you well. You fill out a form, and our customer service team takes care of the rest.
Who am I buying these notes from?
Stuvia is a marketplace, so you are not buying this document from us, but from seller solutiont. Stuvia facilitates payment to the seller.
Will I be stuck with a subscription?
No, you only buy these notes for $8.58. You're not tied to anything after your purchase.
Can Stuvia be trusted?
4.6 stars on Google & Trustpilot (+1000 reviews)
74735 documents were sold in the last 30 days
Founded in 2010, the go-to place to buy study notes for 14 years now